The Roman general who said a white deer told him secrets
Sertorius told the tribes of Spain that the gods spoke to him through a tame white deer. His real source was a messenger in the night.
In short
The Roman general Sertorius, fighting in Spain around 80 BC, was given a white fawn. He tamed it and told the local tribes it was a gift from the goddess Diana that revealed secrets to him. In fact he got his news from messengers and then pretended the deer had told him in a dream. According to Plutarch, the trick made the tribes believe a god was leading them.
Around 80 BC, a Roman general in Spain had a problem. He needed thousands of local fighters to follow him, and he was a foreigner. His answer was a tame white deer.
Who was Sertorius?
Quintus Sertorius was a Roman general who ended up on the losing side of a civil war in Rome. His party lost to the general Sulla, and he sailed to Spain. Later the Lusitanians, a people of the peninsula, sent ambassadors and invited him to be their leader.
His army was tiny. Plutarch counts 2,600 men he called Romans, 700 Libyans, 4,000 lightly armed Lusitanians and 700 horsemen. Against him stood four Roman generals with more than 120,000 soldiers. So the enemy in this story was Roman too.
Most people followed Sertorius of their own free will, Plutarch says. But sometimes he used what the translation calls “cunning devices”. The most important one was the deer.
Where did the white deer come from?
A countryman called Spanus came across a doe that was running from hunters. She had just given birth. He could not catch the mother, but he caught her fawn, which was completely white, and gave it to Sertorius.
Sertorius tamed it so well that it came when he called and walked beside him. It was not even afraid of the noise of an army camp.
What did Sertorius tell the tribes?
Step by step, he turned the animal into something holy. He said the fawn was a gift from the goddess Diana and that it revealed hidden things to him.
Then he made it look true.
- When he received secret news that the enemy had attacked somewhere, he pretended the deer had spoken to him in his sleep and had warned him to keep his troops ready.
- When a messenger brought news of a victory, he hid the messenger. Then he led out the deer wearing garlands, as a sign that good news was coming.
The news always turned out to be right, because it had already happened. Plutarch says the people became convinced that they were led by a god and not by the thinking of a foreigner.
What happened when the deer went missing?
This part is not in our video. Years later, the deer disappeared, and Sertorius was very discouraged. Then some men who were out at night found the animal and caught it.
Sertorius promised them a lot of money if they told no one. He hid the deer for several days. Then he stepped in front of the local leaders with a cheerful face and said that the god had shown him great good fortune in a dream.
While he was hearing requests from his seat, the keepers let the deer go nearby. It saw Sertorius, ran to him, laid its head in his lap and licked his hand. The crowd was amazed. They clapped, cheered and walked him home.
What the video simplified
Our video is 54 seconds long, so some things are shortened or drawn in a simpler way. Here is everything we changed.
| In the video | In the sources |
|---|---|
| Sertorius says “The gods sent me this deer.” | Plutarch names the goddess Diana. All spoken lines in the video are ours. |
| “He tricked his whole army.” | Plutarch says most followed him willingly anyway. The trick made them more obedient. |
| “The enemy” attacks. | The enemy were Roman armies sent from Rome. |
| The deer stays a fawn. | Plutarch describes a fawn that grows into a doe. |
| The deer sleeps while the messenger comes. | This is our picture for the trick. Plutarch only says the news came secretly. |
| The story of the lost deer is missing. | It is told in chapter 20 and summarised above. |
| Sertorius has two eyes. | Plutarch says he had lost one eye in battle. |
| A banner with the letters SPQR. | Our drawing. Sertorius was fighting the government in Rome. |
The look of the tribesmen, the tent and the golden collar is our own drawing.
Did it really happen?
We have it from Plutarch, who wrote more than 150 years after Sertorius died. He does not doubt the story, and he tells it as an example of a clever trick, not as a miracle.
Two other ancient authors, Aulus Gellius and Frontinus, are usually named as telling the same story. We have not read their texts for this article, so we do not use them here. What Plutarch gives us is a general who understood what his followers wanted to believe.
Questions and answers
Did Sertorius really have a white deer?
Plutarch says so. A countryman called Spanus caught a pure white fawn and gave it to Sertorius, who tamed it until it followed him around the camp.
How did the deer trick work?
When Sertorius got secret news that the enemy was attacking, he pretended that the deer had told him in a dream. When news of a victory arrived, he hid the messenger and led out the deer wearing garlands, as if it had brought the good news.
Why did Sertorius need the trick?
He was a Roman leading local fighters with a very small army against much larger Roman forces. Plutarch says the trick made people believe they were led by a god and not by the mind of a foreigner.
What happened when the deer disappeared?
Plutarch tells that the deer went missing and was found by some men at night. Sertorius paid them to keep quiet, hid the animal for several days, announced a lucky dream, and then had the deer released so that it ran to him in front of everyone.
Video transcript
Read what the narrator says
- A Roman general once tricked his whole army with a pet deer. And it worked.
- His name was Sertorius. He was fighting in Spain, and the local tribes did not really trust him. He was a stranger from Rome.
- One day, a man brought him a baby deer. It was white, and soon it followed him everywhere.
- And that gave Sertorius an idea. He told the tribes: The gods sent me this deer. It tells me secrets in my dreams. Of course, that was a lie.
- His secrets really came from messengers. But he said: The deer warned me. The enemy is coming. And then the enemy really came.
- Here is how it worked. At night, a messenger came to his tent in secret, and he gave Sertorius the news.
- The deer was fast asleep. It never knew a thing.
- But the tribes believed the deer was magic. So now they trusted Sertorius, and they followed him.
Sources
- Plutarch, Life of Sertorius, chapters 11, 12 and 20.Our only source for this article. The gift of the fawn, the story about Diana, the messengers, the size of the army and the episode of the lost deer are all here. Translation by Bernadotte Perrin.